Colorado Insurance Bad Faith Claims: What Happens When an Insurer Won’t Pay

Table of Contents

Colorado policyholder reviewing an insurance claim decision

You buy insurance because you expect the company to be there when you need it. You pay the premiums. You submit a legitimate claim. The insurance company should investigate it fairly and pay covered benefits within a reasonable time.

Unfortunately, that does not always happen.

Colorado law prohibits an insurance company from unreasonably delaying or denying covered benefits owed to a first-party claimant. Depending on the facts, an insured may have both a common-law bad faith claim and a statutory claim under C.R.S. §§ 10-3-1115 and 10-3-1116.

Those claims are related, but they are not identical. The proof is different, and the damages can be different.

If you believe your insurance company is delaying payment, ignoring evidence, changing its reasons for denial, or refusing to pay benefits that should be covered, it is important to understand the difference.

This article discusses Colorado insurance bad faith generally. It is not legal advice about a particular insurance claim.

McDowell Law Firm
Get Guidance on an Insurance Dispute
McDowell Law Firm handles personal injury cases and offers personalized legal representation for people navigating high-stakes claims.

What Is Insurance Bad Faith in Colorado?

An insurance company does not commit bad faith simply because it denies a claim or disagrees with you about how much the claim is worth.

The issue is whether the insurance company acted reasonably.

Colorado recognizes a special duty of good faith and fair dealing between an insurance company and its insured. Insurance is different from an ordinary commercial contract because people purchase insurance for financial protection when something goes wrong.

When an insurer handles a claim unreasonably, Colorado law may provide a remedy.

Examples can include:

  • Failing to conduct a reasonable investigation.

  • Ignoring important evidence supporting coverage.

  • Unreasonably delaying a decision.

  • Repeatedly requesting information that has already been provided.

  • Refusing to pay benefits that are no longer reasonably disputed.

  • Relying on policy language that does not reasonably apply.

  • Changing the reason for denying a claim.

  • Unreasonably undervaluing a covered loss.

None of these facts automatically proves bad faith. Insurance companies are allowed to investigate claims and dispute claims when they have a reasonable basis for doing so.

The question is whether the insurer’s conduct was objectively reasonable under the circumstances.

Colorado Has Two Main Types of Insurance Bad Faith Claims

An insured may potentially have two separate claims against an insurance company.

Common-Law Insurance Bad Faith

Colorado courts have recognized the tort of bad faith breach of an insurance contract for decades.

For a first-party common-law bad faith claim, the insured generally must prove:

  1. The insurance company’s conduct was unreasonable.

  2. The insurance company knew its conduct was unreasonable or recklessly disregarded whether it was unreasonable.

That second requirement is important.

It is not enough to show that the insurer ultimately made the wrong decision. Common-law bad faith requires proof concerning the insurer’s state of mind or reckless disregard.

Colorado courts judge the reasonableness of an insurance company’s conduct objectively. Industry standards and claim-handling practices can become important evidence.

Statutory Unreasonable Delay or Denial

Colorado also created a separate statutory remedy through C.R.S. §§ 10-3-1115 and 10-3-1116.

Under C.R.S. § 10-3-1115, a person engaged in the business of insurance may not unreasonably delay or deny payment of a claim for benefits owed to or on behalf of a first-party claimant.

The statutory standard is generally easier to establish than common-law bad faith.

For the statutory claim, the insured does not have to prove that the insurance company knew its conduct was unreasonable or recklessly disregarded that fact.

The primary question is whether the insurer delayed or denied payment of a covered benefit without a reasonable basis.

Who Is a First-Party Claimant?

This distinction is critical.

A first-party claim generally involves benefits you are seeking under an insurance policy that provides coverage to you.

Examples can include:

  • Uninsured or underinsured motorist benefits.

  • Medical payments coverage.

  • Homeowners insurance.

  • Property insurance.

  • Disability insurance in some circumstances.

  • Other benefits payable directly to or on behalf of an insured.

Colorado’s statute expressly excludes a person who is asserting a claim against someone else who is insured under a liability policy.

That means there is a significant difference between these two situations.

If another driver causes a crash and you make an injury claim against that driver’s insurance company, you are generally a third-party claimant.

If the driver who hit you is uninsured or underinsured and you make a UM/UIM claim against your own automobile insurer, you are making a first-party insurance claim.

That difference matters because the statutory remedy under C.R.S. §§ 10-3-1115 and 1116 applies to first-party claimants.

You can read more about UM/UIM claims in our guide to what to do if you are hit by an uninsured driver in Colorado.

An Insurance Company Cannot Hold Undisputed Benefits Hostage

One of the most important Colorado insurance cases is State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. v. Fisher.

Fisher involved an underinsured motorist claim. State Farm agreed that more than $60,000 in medical expenses were reasonable, necessary, and related to the collision. It nevertheless refused to pay those benefits because other portions of the insured’s claim remained disputed.

The Colorado Supreme Court rejected that position.

An insurer cannot simply refuse to pay an undisputed covered benefit because another part of the claim remains disputed.

That rule can become particularly important in UM/UIM cases. An insurance company may legitimately dispute some components of damages while having no reasonable dispute about others.

The existence of one legitimate dispute does not necessarily give the company the right to withhold everything.

A Claim Can Be Unreasonably Delayed Without Being Completely Denied

Bad faith does not require the insurer to send you a letter saying, “Claim denied.”

An unreasonable delay can support a claim.

For example, an insurer might accept that some benefits are covered but repeatedly postpone payment without a reasonable justification.

Colorado law looks at the payment of covered benefits, not merely whether the insurance company eventually closes the entire claim.

That is why the timeline of the claim matters.

When did the insurer receive the evidence?

What did the adjuster know?

When did the insurer recognize that a benefit was covered?

What additional information did the insurer legitimately need?

How long did it take the company to respond?

Those details can determine whether a delay was reasonable.

What Information Can Be Considered in a Bad Faith Case?

A bad faith case generally focuses heavily on what the insurance company knew when it made the challenged decision.

In Schultz v. GEICO Casualty Co., the Colorado Supreme Court explained that the reasonableness of an insurer’s decision must be evaluated based on the information before the insurer at the time of the coverage decision.

That principle makes the claim file extremely important.

Suppose you send your insurer medical records establishing that a surgery resulted from a crash. The insurer denies the claim three weeks later.

The question is not merely whether you can prove causation at trial two years later.

An important question is what evidence the insurer had when it denied the claim and whether its decision was reasonable based on that information.

At the same time, an insurer cannot necessarily defend an unreasonable decision by developing a new justification after litigation begins.

The claim should be evaluated based on the circumstances that existed when the insurer acted.

What Does “Fairly Debatable” Mean?

Insurance companies sometimes argue that a claim was “fairly debatable.”

A genuine dispute about coverage or value is relevant when deciding whether the insurance company acted reasonably.

But “fairly debatable” is not a magic phrase that automatically defeats a bad faith claim.

The Colorado Supreme Court’s decision in Schultz makes clear that the focus remains on whether the insurer acted reasonably based on the information available when it made its decision.

An insurance company cannot simply identify some possible dispute after the fact and treat that as an automatic defense.

What Can You Recover Under C.R.S. § 10-3-1116?

Colorado’s statutory remedy can be significant.

A first-party claimant whose insurance benefits were unreasonably delayed or denied may bring an action to recover:

  • Two times the covered benefit.

  • Reasonable attorney fees.

  • Court costs.

The statute does not require the insured to prove some separate financial injury caused by the delay before recovering the statutory amount.

The “covered benefit” is the benefit that was unreasonably delayed or denied.

Colorado courts have also made clear that the statutory recovery is not necessarily reduced simply because the insurer eventually pays the delayed benefit.

In American Family Mutual Insurance Co. v. Barriga, the Colorado Supreme Court held that the statutory award of two times the covered benefit was not reduced by benefits that the insurance company eventually paid.

Depending on the claims asserted and the facts of the case, an insured may also have a separate breach-of-contract claim to recover benefits owed under the insurance policy. Colorado law permits statutory claims to exist in addition to other available claims, although a claimant cannot obtain an improper double recovery of the same damages.

What Damages Are Available for Common-Law Bad Faith?

Common-law bad faith is a tort.

That means damages are not necessarily limited to what the insurance company should have paid under the policy.

Depending on the evidence, compensatory damages may include economic and noneconomic losses caused by the insurer’s bad faith.

Colorado courts have recognized potential recovery for losses such as:

  • Financial losses caused by the insurer’s conduct.

  • Emotional distress.

  • Inconvenience.

  • Fear and anxiety.

  • Other noneconomic harm resulting from the bad faith conduct.

In an appropriate case, exemplary or punitive damages may also be available under Colorado law.

Punitive damages are not automatic. The evidence must satisfy Colorado’s separate statutory requirements for exemplary damages, including proof of fraud, malice, or willful and wanton conduct.

A finding of ordinary bad faith by itself does not automatically justify punitive damages.

How Long Do You Have to Bring a Colorado Bad Faith Claim?

You should treat the statute of limitations seriously.

A common-law insurance bad faith claim is generally subject to Colorado’s two-year limitation period for tort claims.

Colorado courts apply the discovery rule when determining when a bad faith claim accrues. The important question is generally when the insured discovered, or reasonably should have discovered, the injury and the conduct giving rise to the claim.

Statutory claims under C.R.S. § 10-3-1116 have also been treated as subject to a two-year limitations period. In Rooftop Restoration, Inc. v. American Family Mutual Insurance Co., the Colorado Supreme Court specifically rejected the argument that a § 10-3-1116 claim is governed by Colorado’s one-year limitation period for statutory penalties.

The exact accrual date can still become disputed.

Do not assume you have two years from the date the insurance company finally closes the file. The clock may have started earlier.

If you believe an insurance company has acted improperly, speak with an attorney before the limitation issue becomes close.

The deadline for a bad faith claim can also be different from the deadline governing the underlying accident or insurance claim.

If your insurance dispute arose after a crash, you can read more on our Colorado Springs personal injury lawyer page.

Speak with an attorney about your situation before relying on what you believe the time limit is. If you miss the statute, you can be barred from recovery, even if the claim had merit.

What Should You Save if You Suspect Insurance Bad Faith?

Good documentation can make an enormous difference.

Keep:

  1. Your complete insurance policy, including the declarations page and endorsements.

  2. Every letter from the insurance company.

  3. Every email with the adjuster.

  4. Screenshots or copies of claim-portal messages.

  5. Medical records or other documents you submitted.

  6. Repair estimates.

  7. Medical bills.

  8. Wage-loss documentation.

  9. Photographs and videos.

  10. Copies of demand letters.

  11. Written explanations of coverage decisions.

  12. A timeline of telephone calls and conversations.

When you speak with an adjuster by telephone, write down the date, time, name of the person, and what was discussed.

For important conversations, consider sending a short follow-up email confirming what was discussed.

The issue may later become whether the insurance company had a particular medical record, estimate, photograph, or other document before it made its decision.

You want to be able to answer that question.

Ask the Insurance Company to Explain a Denial

If the insurer denies the claim or refuses to pay part of it, ask for the decision in writing.

You should know:

  • What policy language is the insurer relying on?

  • What facts support the decision?

  • What additional information does the company contend it needs?

  • Is the insurer disputing coverage, damages, causation, or something else?

  • Is any portion of the claim undisputed?

Those questions can expose whether there is a legitimate disagreement or whether the insurer is simply delaying payment.

Bad Faith After a Car Accident

Insurance bad faith frequently becomes an issue after a serious motor vehicle accident.

The first question is whose insurance company you are dealing with.

If another driver caused the accident and you make a bodily injury claim against that driver’s liability insurer, you are generally a third-party claimant. You ordinarily do not have a statutory claim under C.R.S. §§ 10-3-1115 and 1116 simply because the liability carrier is slow, difficult, or makes a low settlement offer.

Your rights can be very different when dealing with your own insurance company.

For example, you may have a first-party claim involving:

  • Uninsured motorist coverage.

  • Underinsured motorist coverage.

  • Medical payments coverage.

  • Collision coverage.

  • Other benefits available under your own policy.

Those claims can create duties that the other driver’s liability insurer does not owe you.

If you were recently injured, our guide on what to do after a car wreck explains several steps you can take to protect your claim.

You can also read our guide on when to hire a personal injury lawyer.

Can You File a Complaint With the Colorado Division of Insurance?

Yes.

The Colorado Division of Insurance accepts consumer complaints concerning insurance companies, agents, and insurance-related conduct.

A regulatory complaint and a lawsuit are different things.

The Division does not become your personal attorney, and filing a complaint does not guarantee that the company will pay the claim.

More importantly, you should not assume that filing a complaint stops a statute of limitations from running.

If you may have a legal claim, address the applicable deadlines separately.

What About ERISA Insurance Plans?

Employer-sponsored benefit plans can create another layer of complexity.

Some employer benefit plans are governed by the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act, commonly called ERISA.

ERISA can preempt state-law claims in some circumstances, which may prevent a claimant from using Colorado bad faith remedies that otherwise might appear to apply.

Do not assume that every insurance policy connected to employment is governed by the same rules.

The policy, the type of plan, who funded it, and how the benefits are administered can all matter.

Does Colorado Bad Faith Law Apply to Every Type of Insurance?

No.

The statutory provisions contain specific exceptions.

For example, C.R.S. §§ 10-3-1115 and 1116 do not apply to insurance issued under Colorado’s Workers’ Compensation Act. Section 10-3-1115 also excludes title insurance and life insurance from those statutory provisions.

There can also be questions about whether the defendant is legally considered a person “engaged in the business of insurance.”

In Hertz Corp. v. Babayev, decided by the Colorado Supreme Court in 2026, the Court held that a rental car company that offered supplemental insurance through an insurer did not itself become an insurer subject to these statutory and common-law insurance duties merely because of that arrangement.

The identity of the defendant can therefore matter as much as the type of claim.

How McDowell Law Firm Can Help

Insurance disputes often develop inside personal injury cases.

A serious car, motorcycle, or truck accident may begin as a claim against the person who caused the collision. It can later become a dispute with your own insurer over uninsured motorist benefits, underinsured motorist benefits, medical payments coverage, or another part of your policy.

McDowell Law Firm represents injured people in Colorado Springs and throughout El Paso County.

I limit my caseload and remain personally involved in my cases. If an insurance company is refusing to pay a serious injury claim, I can review the policy, the correspondence, the evidence submitted to the insurer, and the timeline of the claim to determine what options may be available.

You can learn more on our Colorado Springs personal injury lawyer page.

If you believe an insurance company is delaying or denying benefits without a legitimate reason, do not let the claim sit indefinitely. Evidence gets harder to organize, and statutes of limitation continue to run.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is every denied insurance claim bad faith?

No. An insurance company can deny a claim when it has a reasonable basis for doing so.

The fact that the insurer is eventually proven wrong does not automatically establish bad faith. The focus is whether the company’s investigation, evaluation, and decision were reasonable under the circumstances.

Can an insurance company delay payment without actually denying my claim?

Yes, but an unreasonable delay can itself violate Colorado law.

An insurer does not avoid potential liability simply by keeping a claim technically “open” while refusing to pay covered benefits without a reasonable basis.

Can my insurance company refuse to pay anything because part of my claim is disputed?

Not necessarily.

Under State Farm v. Fisher, an insurer cannot withhold an undisputed covered benefit merely because another portion of the claim remains reasonably disputed.

How much can I recover for unreasonable delay or denial?

Under C.R.S. § 10-3-1116, a successful first-party claimant may recover reasonable attorney fees, court costs, and two times the covered benefit that was unreasonably delayed or denied.

Other claims, including breach of contract or common-law bad faith, may provide additional remedies depending on the facts.

Do I have a bad faith claim against the other driver’s insurance company?

Usually not under C.R.S. §§ 10-3-1115 and 1116.

Colorado’s statutory definition specifically excludes a person asserting a claim against an insured under a liability policy.

Your relationship with your own insurance company is different.

Do I have to prove that the insurance company intentionally tried to hurt me?

Not for a statutory unreasonable-delay claim.

The statutory issue is whether the insurer acted unreasonably by delaying or denying a covered benefit without a reasonable basis.

A common-law first-party bad faith claim requires an additional showing that the insurer knew its conduct was unreasonable or recklessly disregarded that fact.

How long do I have to file an insurance bad faith lawsuit?

Many Colorado bad faith claims are subject to a two-year statute of limitations, but determining when that period began can be complicated.

Do not simply count two years from the date the insurance company sent its final letter. Accrual may have occurred earlier.

An attorney should review the specific dates in your case.

Important Colorado Insurance Bad Faith Cases

Several Colorado cases are particularly important to understanding these claims:

Schultz v. GEICO Casualty Co., 2018 CO 87. The reasonableness of the insurer’s decision is evaluated based on the information before it when the decision was made.

State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. v. Fisher, 2018 CO 39. An insurer cannot unreasonably withhold an undisputed covered benefit merely because another portion of the claim remains disputed.

American Family Mutual Insurance Co. v. Barriga, 2018 CO 42. The statutory award of two times the covered benefit is not reduced because the insurer eventually paid benefits that it had unreasonably delayed.

Rooftop Restoration, Inc. v. American Family Mutual Insurance Co., 2018 CO 44. A claim under C.R.S. § 10-3-1116 is not governed by Colorado’s one-year statute of limitations for statutory penalties.

Goodson v. American Standard Insurance Co., 89 P.3d 409 (Colo. 2004). Common-law bad faith can allow recovery of traditional tort damages, including emotional distress damages where supported by the evidence.

Hertz Corp. v. Babayev, 2026 CO 26. A rental car company offering supplemental insurance through an insurer does not thereby assume the statutory or common-law duties of the insurer.

Sources

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Related Articles

Get In Touch With Us

Request a Free Consultation

Footer Contact Form

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)